Resources for Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)

Critics Rip OSHA's Construction Confined Space Standard

www.ohsonline.com

OSHA's long-awaited construction confined spaces proposed standard is taking its lumps from stakeholders. Several petitioned for an extension in the original comment period after OSHA published the proposal Nov. 28, 2007, and the agency agreed. With comments now due by Feb. 28, small construction companies and some big building groups are weighing in, negatively.

Several elements in the proposal displease the construction community, it appears. Jim Redmond, Safety and Health Services director for General Building Contractors of New York State Inc. (the New York State Building Chapter of Associated General Contractors of America), said his group was troubled to see "controlling contractor" language in the proposed rule because they opposed it in OSHA's steel erection standard and believe it is legally questionable. Redmond mentions a 2007 case, Summit Contractors, in which OSHRC vacated an OSHA citation against the general contractor for allegedly failing to ensure a subcontractor's masonry workers were protected from falls on a job site. This decision, which hsa been appealed by the Labor Department to the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, invalidated OSHA's multi-employer enforcement policy, and Redmond said it is "absurd" to have "controlling contractor" language now used in the confined spaces standard.

View the Resource

Share or bookmarklet this web page at: